In Gettier’s second counterexample, Smith knows that every c…

In Gettier’s second counterexample, Smith knows that every car Jones has ever bought has been a Ford. Yesterday, Jones offered Smith a ride in a Ford. Because of this, Smith believes Jones owns a ford. Therefore, Smith also believes this statement: “Either Jones owns a Ford or Brown is in Barcelona.” even though Smith has no idea where Brown actually is.  It turns out that actually Jones does not own a Ford, but Brown, by lucky coincidence actually is in Barcelona.  Which of the following describes the situation?